Ellicottville softball senior Courtney Marsh got some hardware to cap off her career with the CCAA 4 Player of the Year, while freshman teammate Katie Lafferty took the pitcher of the year award.

The Eagles reached the Section 6 Class D title game this past season, losing a 2-0 contest to Forestville. Ellicottville also had Teaghan Finn, Riley Whitmer and Ande Northrup make the first team while Matt Finn won Coach of the Year.

Portville had three first team selections with Madison Ford, Isabella Morales and Peyton Young. Other local standouts included Franklinville’s Grace Cornell and Lilah Cudney making the first team and Portville’s Alexa Schoonover claiming a second team spot.

The rest of the CCAA 4 All-Star selections are included below

CCAA 4 – 2025 All-Stars

Player of the Year – Courtney Marsh (Ellicottville, Senior)

Pitcher of the Year – Katie Lafferty (Ellicottville, Freshman)

First Team (14)

Riley Preston – Sophomore – CLV

Madison Rogan – Freshman – CLV

Teaghan Finn – Junior – Ellicottville

Ande Northrup – Junior – Ellicottville

Riley Whitmer – Sophomore – Ellicottville

Hannah Melquist – Junior – Falconer

Emily Zaranek – Junior – Falconer

Grace Cornell – 8th Grade – Franklinville

Lilah Cudney – Senior – Franklinville

Madison Ford – Junior – Portville

Isabella Morales – Junior – Portville

Peyton Young – Senior – Portville

Second Team (11)

Abby Terhune – Freshman – CLV

Emma West – Sophomore – CLV

Kalyn Crowley – Junior – Ellicottville

Katrina Schrantz – Senior – Falconer

Nylah Sharpe – Junior – Falconer

Mylie Zaranek – Junior – Falconer

Kaelyann Graves-Decker – Sophomore – Franklinville

Haley Rzucek – Senior – Franklinville

Isabelle Contro – Sophomore – North Collins

Lily Montaldi – Freshman – North Collins

Alexa Schoonover – Junior – Portville

Honorable Mention (10)

Carly Preston – Sophomore – CLV

Drew Ficek – Junior – Ellicottville

Khloe Livengood – Junior – Falconer

Emily Rhinehart – Junior – Falconer

Taylor Chase – Sophomore – Franklinville

Mia Sullivan – Freshman – Franklinville

Eleanor Fricano – Senior – North Collins

Morgan Kreinheder – Sophomore – North Collins

Kylie Maedl – 8th grade – Portville

Ella Zeigler – Sophomore – Portville

Individual Sportsmanship:

CLV – Abby Terhune (Freshman)

Ellicottville –Ava Woodarek (Senior)

Falconer – Nazariah Neal (Senior)

Franklinville – Abbi Chase (Senior)

Portville –Emily Collins (Senior)

North Collins – Eleanor Fricano (Senior)

Coach of the Year: Matt Finn (Ellicottville)

Team Sportsmanship: North Collins